Statement by the Calorie Control Board on the nutrient profile model of PAHO

Statement by the Calorie Control Board on the nutrient profile model of PAHO

The nutrient profile model of the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) was revealed in 2016 and proposed new standards to outline excessive ranges of sugar, salt and fats in processed meals and beverages. The target of this model is to offer a software that can be used in the design and implementation of insurance policies related to the prevention and control of obesity or obese, together with restrictions on the advertising of unhealthy meals and beverages addressed to youngsters, norms for food in the faculty surroundings (food packages and sale of food and drinks in faculties), use of warning labels on the entrance of the container, definition of fiscal insurance policies to restrict the consumption of unhealthy foods and identification of food that might be offered by social packages to weak groups.

In relation to sugar, the
PAHO affirms that the “best available scientific evidence” was reviewed with a view to
classify processed and ultra-processed meals and beverages as merchandise
with “excessive” ranges of sugar if the amount of sugar added is equal or
larger than 10% of complete calories. The model also specifies that the
products whose components embrace caloric or non-caloric synthetic sweeteners
or pure, have to be defined as products “that include other
sweeteners “, which must be restricted or prevented.

The advice to limit or
keep away from non-nutritive sweeteners, which is a component of the suggestions
of WHO / PAHO relating to the reduction of sugars, is problematic since
does not take note of the established benefits and the safety of these
elements and discourages the use of merchandise that can be an necessary
software for weight administration and to answer sure

Non-nutritive sweeteners and weight management

The profile model of
PAHO Vitamins Cites Literature
which indicates that there was a proportional improve in the
the sale of drinks sweetened with sugar and the physique mass index (BMI) of
the common inhabitants in Latin America. This assertion only highlights one of the
elements of the complete weight-reduction plan and does not handle the giant body of proof suggesting the position that non-nutritive sweeteners fulfill in the
reduction of power intake and body weight. After making a
deep analysis and evaluation of the out there evidence, in the Consensus
Iberoamericano of 2018 it was concluded that the use of sweeteners does not
dietary packages in weight discount packages, as an alternative to
caloric sweeteners, might favor a sustainable weight discount
inside the context of structured meals plans.

Additionally, in a evaluate
systematic assessment and a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials,
carried out in 2019, no vital differences have been present in the change
of physique weight of adults who acquired non-nutritive sweeteners in
comparability with those that acquired totally different sugars or placebo. These
findings seem to point that there are other parts in the weight loss plan or elements of
way of life to which weight achieve may be attributed. Likewise, studies have additionally proven that the impact of consuming sweetened beverages with
Non-nutritive sweeteners to shed pounds is just like consuming water. The suggestion that products containing
non-nutritive sweeteners have the similar effect on BMI as sweeteners
with sugar isn’t backed by all of the scientific proof
out there and, finally, deprive shoppers of a software
Useful backed by science to assist manage weight.

Non-nutritive sweeteners and the administration of diabetes

Sweeteners do not
nutritious, when used as an alternative to sugar, not only have the
potential to help individuals obtain and keep a wholesome weight,
but additionally they serve to handle the blood glucose levels of
those who have diabetes. In a assessment of current analysis on sucralose, carried out in 2017,
ratified the findings of previous evaluations and it was reported that, provided that
sucralose shouldn’t be digested or metabolized to provide power, it doesn’t contribute
energy and does not affect blood glucose ranges. Subsequently, the
meals and drinks containing sucralose are appropriate for individuals with
diabetes or those who try to scale back calorie consumption or

From some extent of view
international, after a careful assessment of the scientific literature
obtainable, the panel on dietetic products, vitamin and allergic reactions of the
The European Food Security Authority (EFSA) concluded that the alternative of
foods that include sugar by meals that include sweeteners don’t
vitamins induces a smaller improve in blood glucose levels then
of your consumption. In the Ibero-American Consensus of 2018 it was concluded that the use of
non-nutritive sweeteners in diabetes management packages can
contribute to raised glycemic control in sufferers. Finally, the
The European Commission approved a declaration of well being concerning non-nutritive sweeteners and post-prandial glucose based mostly on
this finding.

The security of non-nutritive sweeteners

Scientific organizations
international and regulatory bodies, corresponding to the Committee
Joint FAO / WHO Professional Committee on Meals Components (JECFA), the Administration
of Medicine and Foods in the US UU (FDA) and the European Authority
Meals Security Company (EFSA) have extensively reviewed the
non-nutritive sweeteners and acknowledged their safety. In a assessment of
scope on the safety of non-nutritive sweeteners and their
association to sure health outcomes, carried out in 2017, was not discovered
No conclusive evidence of the harmful results of the use of sweeteners is

The position of WHO / PAHO of
limit or keep away from non-nutritive sweeteners as half of their suggestions
of sugar reduction suggests that these sweeteners contribute to the
weight problems and diabetes when, in reality, its useful results are due,
in large part, to the alternative of sugar in the food plan. Consequently, it have to be
recognize non-nutritive sweeteners as a software for managing
of weight and diabetes and not as an obstacle. Advocate the reduction of
elements which have a substantial amount of evidence that supports
your safety and your health benefits might, in reality, cause
unexpected consequences, resembling confusion between shoppers and a lowered
availability of merchandise which are essential for disease administration
related to weight-reduction plan. As the current recommendations and the subsequent
national laws could also be too restrictive for some
shoppers, they could select to disregard the tips utterly and comply with
together with your consumption habits. We encourage
WHO and PAHO to rigorously evaluation the scientific literature on
non-nutritive sweeteners, rethink their suggestions and, finally,
encourage the incorporation of these elements that can be used to help
to scale back caloric intake and handle physique weight and glucose ranges
in the blood.


Gardner C, Wylie-Rosett J,
Gidding SS, Steffen LM, Johnson RK, Reader D and Lichtenstein AH. Nonnutritive
Sweeteners: Present Use and Well being Perspectives. Circulation. 2012;

Fee, European. (2012).
Fee Regulation (EU) No 432/2012 of 16 Might 2012. Official Journal of the
European Union. 1-40.

Lohner S, Toews I, Meerpohl
JJ Health outcomes of non-nutritive
sweeteners: analysis of the research landscape. Nutr J 2017; 16:55.

Magnuson BA, Roberts A, and
Nestmann ER. Important assessment of the current literature on the safety of
sucralose. Food Chem Toxicol 2017 Aug; 106 (Pt A): 324-355. doi:
10.1016 / j.fct.2017.05.047

Nichol AD, Maxwell JH &
Ruopeng A. (2018). Glycemic influence of non-nutritive sweeteners: a scientific
assessment and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Eur J of Clin Nutr 2018; 72. 10.1038 / s41430-018-0170-6.

Pan American Health
Organization (PAHO) (2016) Pan American Health Group Nutrient Profile
Model Washington, D.C.

Peters JC, Wyatt HR, Foster
GD, Pan Z, Wojtanowski AC, Vander Veur SS et al. The consequences of water and
non-nutritive sweetened beverages on weight loss during a 12-week weight loss
remedy program Obesity 2014; 22:

Rogers PJ, Hogenkamp PS, from
Graaf C, Higgs S, Lluch A, Ness AR, Penfold C, Perry R, ​​Putz P, Yeomans MR, et
to the. Does low-energy sweeten ff ect power consumption and body weight?
A scientific evaluate, including meta-analyzes, of the proof from human and
animal studies. Int J Obes (Lond)
2016; 40: 381-94.

Serra-Majem L, Raposo A,
Aranceta-Bartrina J, Varela-Moreiras G, Logue C, Laviada H, Socolovsky S,
Pérez-Rodrigo C, Aldrete-Velasco J, Meneses Sierra E, et al. Ibero-American
Consensus on Low- and No-Calorie Sweeteners: Security, Dietary Features and
Bene fi ts in Meals and Beverages. Vitamins 2018; 10: 81

Tate DF, Turner-McGrievy G,
Lyons E, Stevens J, Erickson Okay, Polzien Okay et al. Changing caloric beverages
with water or food regimen drinks for weight loss in adults: major results of the
Select Healthy Options Consciously Everyday (CHOICE) randomized medical trial. Am J Clin Nutr 2012; 95: 555-563

Toews I, Lohner S, Küllenberg
by Gaudry D, et al. Association between intake of non-sugar sweeteners and
well being outcomes: systematic evaluation and meta-analyzes of randomized and
Non-randomized controlled trials and observational research. BMJ. 2019 Jan 2; 364: okay4718. doi:
10.1136 / bmj.okay4718.

Extremely-processed meals and
drink products in Latin America: Tendencies, influence on weight problems, coverage
implications Washington D.C .: Pan American Well being Group, 2015